← All posts

Survivor ELO Blog

PROBST, SHALLOW & BEAST Recap, Survivor 51 Episode 8

Published: 2026-11-14

Jelly's idol cancelled 8 votes, and Kristin and Kilby went out 1-0 on Devin's vote at 7.7% and 6.1%; for Episode 9 PROBST has Jelly at 36.6% to go home

TL;DR: The 12 players were voted out in pairs. Jelly's idol cancelled the 8 votes for Jelly and Devin, and Devin's vote, the only one that counted, sent Kristin and Kilby home 1-0. PROBST had Kristin at 7.7%, 6th of 12, and Kilby at 6.1%, 7th, and gave 2 eliminations in the episode 18%. For Episode 9 PROBST has Jelly at 36.6% to go home and Devin at 26.2%.


Episode Summary: SurvivorElo Episode 8

Quick refresher: PROBST (PRobabilistic Odds for Boots, Swaps and Tribals) forecasts each episode before it airs: who goes home, which tribe goes to tribal council, and whether the tribes swap or merge. Each recap scores the last forecast and sets out the next one; the Predictions page has this week's odds. Among its inputs are 2 ratings. SHALLOW rates strategic positioning (voting correctly + outlasting). BEAST rates challenge performance. Both use Elo, so gains and losses depend on relative ratings. Full methodology at survivorelo.com.


How PROBST Called Episode 8

PROBST published these odds before the episode aired. It forecasts one player at a time and has no rule for a pairs vote, so it scores Kristin and Kilby as 2 boots. "Votes land on" is who the votes fall on before idols and immunity are settled.

Player Partner Goes home Votes land on Result
Eric Thien An 16.1% 15.3% Voted Jelly and Devin; given Cristian's extra vote, did not use it
Mike Maggie 12.9% 12.6% Voted Jelly and Devin
Lewis Sharonda 11.8% 11.4% Won immunity; voted Jelly and Devin
Thien An Eric 9.7% 9.3% Voted Jelly and Devin
Devin Jelly 9.3% 9.0% Saved by Jelly's idol; cast the only vote that counted
Kristin Kilby 7.7% 7.4% Voted out, 1-0; her Shot in the Dark was not safe
Kilby Kristin 6.1% 5.7% Voted out, 1-0; voted Jelly and Devin
Maggie Mike 6.1% 5.7% Voted Jelly and Devin
Cristian Carter 5.8% 5.5% Played a Shot in the Dark, safe
Carter Cristian 5.1% 7.2% Voted Jelly and Devin; safe with Cristian
Sharonda Lewis 5.0% 4.7% Won immunity; voted Jelly and Devin
Jelly Devin 4.4% 6.3% Played her idol for herself and Devin; voted Cristian and Carter

Both boots were below an even share. With 12 players an even share is 8.3%. Kristin was 6th at 7.7% and Kilby 7th at 6.1%. PROBST had 1 tribal council at 86% and 2 eliminations at 18%; the episode had 1 tribal council and 2 eliminations.

The votes landed on the idol holder. Of the 10 votes cast, 8 went to Jelly and Devin. PROBST had the votes landing on Jelly at 6.3%, 8th of 12, and on Devin at 9.0%, 5th. Jelly's chance of going home, 4.4%, was the lowest in the cast because she held an idol, and the idol saved her and Devin.

The first pick was 1 of the 8. Eric was 1st at 16.1%, for "received votes last tribal" and "has received votes". Eric voted Jelly and Devin and held Cristian's extra vote, which he did not use.

Immunity. PROBST forecasts individual immunity, and this week it was won by a pair. It had Lewis 2nd at 12.6% and Sharonda last of 12 at 3.7%. Mike, 1st at 16.7%, finished with Maggie 5th of the 6 pairs.

The track record uses the new data. This week survivoR also added finishing orders to 169 older individual challenges, which changes BEAST for past players (see BEAST and the New Challenge Data). With the new data the track record scores Kristin at 7.8%, 6th, and Kilby at 6.0%, 8th. Earlier boots move by 0.1 points or less; the "If tribe votes" numbers move by up to 0.8.

The Season So Far

Episode Voted out Forecast Rank If tribe votes
1 Aaliyah 5.0% 2nd of 20 10.0%
2 Ana 4.9% 14th of 19 10.6%
3 Patt 4.1% 15th of 19 8.8%
4 Jenna 6.0% 4th of 17 6.5%
5 Alexis 14.6% 1st of 16 37.6%
5 Linnea 3.4% 14th of 16 9.1%
6 Ori 13.5% 1st of 14 52.5%
7 Brady 7.7% 8th of 13 8.5%
8 Kristin 7.8% 6th of 12 7.8%
8 Kilby 6.0% 8th of 12 6.0%

Rob's quit in Episode 3 is not scored. From Episode 7, "If tribe votes" is the merged tribe.

Measure PROBST At random
First pick went home 20% (2 of 10) 7%
Boot in its top 3 30% (3 of 10) 20%
Boot in its top 5 40% (4 of 10) 33%
Average rank of the boot 7.30 8.40
Log loss (lower is better) 2.725 2.744

Kristin and Kilby both score worse than picking at random, and the log loss gap narrows from 0.067 to 0.019. PROBST stays ahead on every measure. A sample of 10 boots is small; the backtest on past seasons is on the Predictions page.


Episode 8: What Happened

Tree mail told the 12 players to pick partners for the immunity challenge: Carter and Cristian, Devin and Jelly, Eric and Thien An, Kilby and Kristin, Lewis and Sharonda, and Maggie and Mike. Before the challenge they learned that the pairs would be voted out together, and Jeff Probst told them that Brady had left Ponderosa to treat his injured thumb. Lewis and Sharonda won immunity and a spaghetti feast, and took Jelly and Kristin with them; Kristin and Kilby finished last. Lewis and Sharonda sent Cristian on a journey, where he risked his vote, won it back, and earned an extra vote good only at this tribal council. At tribal council Cristian gave the extra vote to Eric, who did not use it. Kristin and Cristian played Shots in the Dark: Kristin's was not safe, and Cristian's made him and Carter safe. Jelly played her idol for herself and Devin and cancelled the 8 votes against them. Jelly's vote for Cristian and Carter did not count. Devin's vote for Kristin and Kilby was the only one left, and they went out 1-0 as the first 2 members of the jury.


The Pairs Vote

PROBST had Kristin at 7.7% and Kilby at 6.1%. survivoR records the pairs vote as 2 votes at the same tribal council, one for each member of a pair, so every ballot below counts twice.

Player Partner Vote Vote record Outlast record Start End Change
Devin Jelly Kristin and Kilby 19-0 2-0 1515.2 1562.0 (B) +46.8
Cristian Carter Shot in the Dark 0-0 2-0 1543.1 1551.3 (B) +8.2
Carter Cristian Jelly and Devin 0-2 2-0 1475.1 1481.5 (C) +6.4
Lewis Sharonda Jelly and Devin 0-2 2-0 1498.1 1503.7 (C) +5.6
Thien An Eric Jelly and Devin 0-2 2-0 1507.7 1512.9 (C) +5.2
Jelly Devin Cristian and Carter 0-2 2-0 1515.2 1520.1 (C) +4.9
Mike Maggie Jelly and Devin 0-2 2-0 1519.7 1524.5 (C) +4.8
Eric Thien An Jelly and Devin 0-2 2-0 1543.1 1547.1 (B) +4.0
Sharonda Lewis Jelly and Devin 0-2 2-0 1543.1 1547.1 (B) +4.0
Maggie Mike Jelly and Devin 0-2 2-0 1561.2 1564.6 (B) +3.4
Kristin Kilby Shot in the Dark 0-1 1-11 1539.3 1495.8 (C) -43.5
Kilby Kristin Jelly and Devin 0-2 1-11 1564.7 1514.8 (C) -49.9

Devin's vote moved the most. Devin cast the only vote that counted and won 19 vote matchups without a loss, for +46.8, the largest single episode gain of the season. Carter's +29.9 in Episode 3 had been the largest. Devin goes from 8th of the 12 left, level with Jelly, to 2nd, at 1562.0, 2.6 behind Maggie.

The 8 lost to 1. Of the 8 players who voted Jelly and Devin, the 7 still in the game each lost 2 vote matchups, both to Devin, and won 2 outlasts, over Kristin and Kilby. They gain 3.4 to 6.4. Jelly's vote for Cristian and Carter also counted as wrong, and Jelly gains 4.9.

Kilby leaves at 1514.8. Kilby went in 1st in the cast at 1564.7, 12-0 on the vote, and drops 49.9. Kilby is now 12-2 and leaves with 5 tribal councils, enough to be established, with Devin and Jelly. Kristin drops 43.5 to 1495.8. SHALLOW counts Kristin and Kilby as outlasting each other, so the 2 matchups between them nearly cancel.

Cristian's Shot in the Dark worked. A player who plays a Shot in the Dark casts no vote, so Cristian has no vote matchups this week; his +8.2 is 2 outlasts. Kristin's 1 vote loss is from being voted out: SHALLOW scores the player voted out as on the wrong side of that vote. Cristian's is the first of the season's 5 Shots in the Dark to work. Aaliyah and Jenna in Episode 1, Ori in Episode 6 and Kristin this week were not safe.


What PROBST Expects in Episode 9

The 10 players are 1 tribe, so the forecast is who goes home and who wins immunity.

Player Original tribe Goes home Votes land on Why
Jelly Toka 36.6% 36.8% received votes last tribal; has received votes; targeted by players still here pulls the other way
Devin Toka 26.2% 26.2% received votes last tribal; has received votes; right side of last vote pulls the other way
Eric Savu 6.7% 6.5% original tribe in the minority; not a challenge threat pulls the other way
Mike Toka 6.6% 6.5% challenge threat; no votes last tribal and no votes received pull the other way
Lewis Toka 5.3% 5.1% challenge threat; no votes last tribal and no votes received pull the other way
Everyone else 3.6-4.5%
Carter Savu 2.2% 3.0% challenge threat; original tribe in the minority; in the largest bloc pulls the other way

With 10 players an even share is 10%. Jelly's 36.6% is more than twice Eric's 16.1% last week, which had been PROBST's highest for any player this season across all scenarios. Carter holds the only idol survivoR records in the game, and his chance of going home, 2.2%, is below where the votes land, 3.0%. For individual immunity PROBST has Mike at 16.8%, Lewis at 14.9% and Carter at 12.4%. It has 1 tribal council at 88% and 2 eliminations at 15%.

The 8 cancelled votes count. PROBST counts votes an idol cancels as votes received. The votes for Jelly and Devin did not count, and "received votes last tribal" is the main reason both are at the top. "Right side of last vote" lowers Devin's number: Devin's vote was the one that counted.

A fix this week. survivoR records the pairs vote as 2 votes, the first naming Jelly and the second naming Devin. PROBST read them as 2 tribal councils and kept only the second as the last one, which gave Devin 8 "votes received last tribal" and Jelly 0. It now counts them as 1 tribal council, with 8 votes for each. Before the fix PROBST had Devin at 34.7% and Jelly at 15.7%.

PROBST sees 3 blocs. From shared votes, it groups Carter, Lewis, Maggie, Mike and Thien An, who have voted together 77% of the time on average; Cristian, Eric and Sharonda, who always have; and Devin and Jelly, 75%. "In the largest bloc" lowers Carter's and Maggie's numbers.

Season odds. The rest of the season is simulated 10,000 times.

Player Original tribe Final 3 Wins Last week
Carter Savu 48.2% 15.9% 9.8%
Sharonda Savu 35.5% 12.0% 10.2%
Lewis Toka 31.8% 11.9% 8.4%
Eric Savu 33.2% 11.4% 7.7%
Cristian Savu 34.6% 9.9% 6.6%

With 10 players an even share is 10%. Carter rises from 9.8% to 15.9%, the largest rise of the week. Jelly, PROBST's leader last week at 13.0%, drops to 5.6%, the lowest left, and has the worst average place in the simulation, 7.5 of 10.

PROBST has no jury. Kristin and Kilby are the first 2 jurors, with Brady gone from Ponderosa. PROBST treats each merged episode as 1 tribe with no pairs, and an individual immunity winner for each vote, and its season odds have no number for making the jury.


Season to Date: SHALLOW Rankings

Devin, Jelly and Kilby are the established players in the cast. The rest are provisional (fewer than 5 tribal councils); rankings show them when the Survivor 51 filter is on.

Rank Player Original tribe Vote record Elo Season
1 Maggie Toka 12-2 1564.6 (B) +64.6
2 Devin Toka 26-12 1562.0 (B) +62.0
3 Cristian Savu 7-0 1551.3 (B) +51.3
4 Eric Savu 7-2 1547.1 (B) +47.1
4 Sharonda Savu 7-2 1547.1 (B) +47.1
6 Mike Toka 7-8 1524.5 (C) +24.5
7 Jelly Toka 7-14 1520.1 (C) +20.1
8 Thien An Toka 8-11 1512.9 (C) +12.9
9 Lewis Toka 5-11 1503.7 (C) +3.7
10 Carter Savu 5-18 1481.5 (C) -18.5

Eliminated

Player Original tribe Vote record Elo Season
Ori Savu 5-2 1517.5 (C) +17.5
Kilby Toka 12-2 1514.8 (C) +14.8
Alexis Savu 4-3 1501.4 (C) +1.4
Linnea Savu 3-0 1499.9 (C) -0.1
Jenna Toka 5-4 1496.1 (C) -3.9
Kristin Savu 7-1 1495.8 (C) -4.2
Patt Toka 3-6 1453.2 (D) -46.8
Aaliyah Toka 0-6 1440.0 (D) -60.0
Ana Savu 0-7 1436.0 (D) -64.0
Brady Toka 3-15 1419.8 (D) -80.2
Rob Savu 0-7 1410.7 (D) -89.3

Cristian, at 7-0, is the only player left who has not lost a vote matchup.


Quick Hits

  • Devin had 1 confessional in Episode 8, the fewest of the 12, and cast the only vote that counted.
  • The player voted out no longer has the most confessionals. From Episode 5 to Episode 7 the boot led the episode; in Episode 8 Cristian had 8 and Carter 7, and Kristin and Kilby had 3 each.
  • Jelly's idol is the first played this season. Carter holds the idol Rob gave him in Episode 3, and Devin still holds the extra vote he found in Episode 3.

BEAST Update

The immunity challenge was run in pairs, and BEAST scores it as a team challenge: Lewis and Sharonda each beat the other 10, with K divided by the size of a player's own side, 2 for the winners and 10 for everyone else.

Player Partner BEAST Change
Sharonda Lewis 1415.9 (D) +40.1
Lewis Sharonda 1590.4 (A) +24.5
The other 10 -1.0 to -1.7

Sharonda gains more than Lewis. Sharonda went in at 1375.8, the lowest in the cast, and Lewis at 1565.8. Beating the other 10 was the bigger upset for Sharonda.

Cristian is now last in the cast. Cristian, at 1409.6, has the lowest BEAST of the 21 in the cast; Sharonda is 2nd lowest. Mike keeps the highest BEAST left at 1637.2 (S), and Lewis is 2nd at 1590.4.

Past players moved around the cast. survivoR's new finishing orders do not change the cast's ratings, since every individual challenge this season already had a full order. They do change the ranks. Mike is 15th of the 874 players BEAST rates, down from 13th, though his rating fell only 1.7: Mike Holloway, Cole Medders and Nick Wilson moved above him, and Boston Rob moved below. BEAST and the New Challenge Data has the details.

PROBST reads these ratings as "challenge threat" and "not a challenge threat". Mike, Lewis and Carter, PROBST's top 3 for immunity, have 3 of the 4 highest BEAST ratings left.


Explore the full rankings, player histories, season snapshots and predictions at survivorelo.com.

Thanks to Dan Oehm (@danoehm.bsky.social) for his survivoR R package, which provides the underlying data.

Player Profiles