← All posts

Survivor ELO Blog

PROBST, SHALLOW & BEAST Recap, Survivor 51 Episode 7

Published: 2026-11-07

The merge came at 75% and Brady went out 9-4 at 8.4% if merged, 6th of 13; for Episode 8 PROBST has Eric at 16.1% to go home

TL;DR: The merge came, at 75% from the data alone, and Brady went out 9-4 at 8.4%, 6th of 13 if merged; across every scenario PROBST had Brady at 7.7%, the same as an even share. The 4 players PROBST had highest if merged were original Savu, and all 4 voted Brady out with Mike, Devin, Jelly, Kilby and Maggie, splitting what PROBST had as the largest bloc. For Episode 8 PROBST has Eric at 16.1% to go home and Mike, who has the highest BEAST in the cast, at 12.9%.


Episode Summary: SurvivorElo Episode 7

Quick refresher: PROBST (PRobabilistic Odds for Boots, Swaps and Tribals) forecasts each episode before it airs: who goes home, which tribe goes to tribal council, and whether the tribes swap or merge. Each recap scores the last forecast and sets out the next one; the Predictions page has this week's odds. Among its inputs are 2 ratings. SHALLOW rates strategic positioning (voting correctly + outlasting). BEAST rates challenge performance. Both use Elo, so gains and losses depend on relative ratings. Full methodology at survivorelo.com.


How PROBST Called Episode 7

PROBST published these odds before the episode aired. The preview had shown the merge, so the Predictions page led with the odds if the tribes merged; "Across all" mixes the merge (75%), a swap (3%) and the tribes staying as they were (22%), and is the number the track record scores.

Player Original tribe If merged Across all Result
Eric Savu 11.1% 10.1% Received 4 votes
Cristian Savu 9.9% 8.9% Voted Brady
Sharonda Savu 9.7% 8.7% Voted Brady; holds Kristin's Tethered Idol
Kristin Savu 9.4% 8.9% Voted Brady; gave Sharonda the Tethered Idol
Mike Toka 8.8% 8.1% Won immunity; voted Brady
Brady Toka 8.4% 7.7% Voted out, 9-4
Devin Toka 8.2% 14.4% Voted Brady

The merge came, and Brady was 6th. PROBST does not use previews and gave the merge 75% from the data. It had 1 tribal council as the likeliest outcome, at 85%, and that is what happened. If merged, Brady was 6th of 13 at 8.4%; with Mike immune, 5th of the 12 who could go. The reasons PROBST gave were "wrong side of last vote" and "challenge threat", with "in the largest bloc" pulling the other way. Across all scenarios Brady was 7.7%, 8th of 13, and with 13 players an even share is also 7.7%.

Across all, the first pick was Devin. If the tribes had stayed as they were, Savu was Devin and Jelly, and PROBST had Devin at 71.7% to go if Savu lost. That put Devin 1st across all scenarios at 14.4%, against 8.2% if merged, 7th of 13. The tribes merged, and Devin voted Brady.

The top 4 voted together. "Original tribe in the minority" put Eric, Cristian, Sharonda and Kristin, 4 of the 5 original Savu players, at the top. Eric drew the 4 votes against. The other 3 voted Brady, as did Eric.

The largest bloc split. From shared votes, PROBST grouped Brady, Kilby, Maggie, Mike and Thien An as the largest bloc. Kilby, Maggie and Mike voted Brady; Brady and Thien An voted Eric, with Lewis and Carter. "In the largest bloc" lowered Brady's number, and Mike's; Mike helped vote Brady out.

Immunity. PROBST had Brady at 9.5% to win individual immunity, Carter at 9.3% and Cristian at 9.1%. Mike won it at 9.0%, 4th of 13.

The Season So Far

Episode Voted out Forecast Rank If tribe votes
1 Aaliyah 5.0% 2nd of 20 10.0%
2 Ana 4.9% 14th of 19 10.6%
3 Patt 4.1% 15th of 19 8.8%
4 Jenna 6.0% 4th of 17 6.5%
5 Alexis 14.5% 1st of 16 37.3%
5 Linnea 3.3% 14th of 16 9.1%
6 Ori 13.4% 1st of 14 51.7%
7 Brady 7.7% 8th of 13 8.4%

Rob's quit in Episode 3 is not scored. For Episode 7, "If tribe votes" is the merged tribe.

Measure PROBST At random
First pick went home 25% (2 of 8) 6%
Boot in its top 3 38% (3 of 8) 18%
Boot in its top 5 50% (4 of 8) 30%
Average rank of the boot 7.38 8.88
Log loss (lower is better) 2.741 2.808

Brady's 7.7% scores about the same as picking at random, so PROBST stays ahead on every measure, by a little less: the log loss gap narrows from 0.077 to 0.067. A sample of 8 boots is small; the backtest on past seasons is on the Predictions page.


Episode 7: What Happened

The 13 players merged: 8 original Toka and 5 original Savu. At the merge, the first 10 to eat 2 grubs earned a seat at the feast. Brady finished first; Cristian and Kristin gave up, and Sharonda finished 11th, behind Kilby. Kristin handed the Tethered Idol to Sharonda to hold. Maggie wanted Kristin out over what Kristin might have brought back from Exile. Mike warned Kristin, Kristin told Brady, and Brady confronted Mike and moved his side to Eric. Mike, Devin and Jelly worked with the original Savu players against Brady, and Kilby and Maggie joined them. Mike won the first individual immunity, balancing a whale figure on a pedestal with a pole, and beat Lewis at the end; Sharonda dropped first. No idol was played. Brady was voted out 9-4 over Eric and is the first member of the jury.


The Merge Vote

PROBST had Brady at 8.4% if merged, 5th of the 12 who could go. All 13 players voted. The 9 who voted Brady each beat the 4 who voted Eric; Brady lost to all 9 and was outlasted by the other 12.

Player Original tribe Vote Vote record Outlast record Start End Change
Devin Toka Brady 4-0 1-0 1493.9 1515.2 (C) +21.3
Jelly Toka Brady 4-0 1-0 1493.9 1515.2 (C) +21.3
Mike Toka Brady 4-0 1-0 1498.8 1519.7 (C) +20.9
Kristin Savu Brady 4-0 1-0 1519.5 1539.3 (B) +19.8
Cristian Savu Brady 4-0 1-0 1523.5 1543.1 (B) +19.6
Eric Savu Brady 4-0 1-0 1523.5 1543.1 (B) +19.6
Sharonda Savu Brady 4-0 1-0 1523.5 1543.1 (B) +19.6
Maggie Toka Brady 4-0 1-0 1542.7 1561.2 (B) +18.5
Kilby Toka Brady 4-0 1-0 1546.4 1564.7 (B) +18.3
Carter Savu Eric 0-9 1-0 1505.9 1475.1 (C) -30.8
Lewis Toka Eric 0-9 1-0 1531.9 1498.1 (C) -33.8
Thien An Toka Eric 0-9 1-0 1542.7 1507.7 (C) -35.0
Brady Toka Eric 0-9 0-12 1498.8 1419.8 (D) -79.0

A merged vote moves more. With 13 players at 1 tribal council, each player had up to 12 opponents. Brady lost 21 matchups, 9 votes and 12 outlasts, for -79.0, the largest single episode drop of the season; Rob's -65.3 when Rob quit in Episode 3 had been the largest. Brady leaves at 1419.8, the 2nd lowest of the 21 in the cast, above only Rob.

The lowest rated gained the most. The 9 in the majority each won 5 matchups. Devin and Jelly, who went in lowest at 1493.9, gain 21.3 each; Kilby, who went in highest at 1546.4, gains 18.3. Carter, Lewis and Thien An each lost 9 vote matchups and won 1 outlast, over Brady, and drop 30.8 to 35.0. Thien An went in level with Maggie at 1542.7 and now trails Maggie by 53.5.

Kilby leads the cast. Kilby is 12-0 on the vote and 1564.7, and Maggie 12-0 and 1561.2. Cristian, Eric, Kristin and Sharonda are 7-0, so 6 of the 12 left have yet to lose a vote matchup.


What PROBST Expects in Episode 8

The 12 players are 1 tribe, so the forecast is who goes home and who wins immunity.

Player Original tribe Goes home Why
Eric Savu 16.1% received votes last tribal; has received votes; not a challenge threat pulls the other way
Mike Toka 12.9% challenge threat; right side of last vote and no votes received pull the other way
Lewis Toka 11.8% challenge threat; wrong side of last vote; no votes received pulls the other way
Thien An Toka 9.7% wrong side of last vote; not a challenge threat and no votes received pull the other way
Devin Toka 9.3% challenge threat
Everyone else 5.0-7.7%
Jelly Toka 4.4% challenge threat

With 12 players an even share is 8.3%. Eric, the only player left who received votes at the last tribal council, is 1st. The 2 idol holders are low: Jelly is last at 4.4%, and Carter is at 5.1%. For individual immunity PROBST has Mike at 16.7%, Lewis at 12.6% and Carter at 11.2%. It has 1 tribal council at 86% and 2 at 13%.

BEAST now drives the forecast. Episode 7's 2 individual challenges moved BEAST more than any episode this season (see the BEAST Update), and "challenge threat" is now the first reason PROBST gives for Mike, Lewis, Devin, Carter and Jelly. Before Episode 7 it was 3rd of Mike's and Brady's reasons. "Not a challenge threat" lowers the numbers for Sharonda, Cristian, Kilby, Thien An and Eric, whose BEAST ratings fell.

PROBST now sees 3 blocs. From shared votes, it groups Carter, Kilby, Lewis, Maggie and Thien An, who have voted together 73% of the time on average; Cristian, Eric, Kristin and Sharonda, who always have; and Devin, Jelly and Mike, 78%. The largest bloc puts Kilby and Maggie with 3 of the 4 who voted Eric, and "in the largest bloc" lowers Kilby's and Maggie's numbers. PROBST cannot see camp life: Inside Survivor has Kilby and Maggie leaving Brady's side for this vote.

Kristin's Tethered Idol is with Sharonda. Only Kristin can play it, only for Sharonda now that Ori is out. PROBST now has Sharonda holding it, and counts an idol held for a player like an idol another player could lend them, at the same low rate. Jelly and Carter hold idols, so that rate already applies to every player without one, and the Tethered Idol adds nothing to Sharonda's 5.0%.

Season odds. The rest of the season is simulated 10,000 times.

Player Original tribe Final 3 Wins Last week
Jelly Toka 32.0% 13.0% 11.5%
Devin Toka 23.5% 10.8% 8.8%
Sharonda Savu 29.9% 10.2% 5.8%
Carter Savu 34.0% 9.8% 10.3%
Kilby Toka 25.9% 9.1% 8.1%

With 12 players an even share is 8.3%. Sharonda rises from 5.8% to 10.2%, the largest rise of the week. Mike, with the highest BEAST in the cast and immunity last week, has the lowest odds to win, 5.1%, and the worst average place in the simulation, 7.6 of 12.

PROBST has no jury. Brady is the first juror. PROBST treats each merged episode as 1 tribe with 1 individual immunity winner, and its season odds have no number for making the jury.


Season to Date: SHALLOW Rankings

Devin and Jelly are the only established players in the cast. The rest are provisional (fewer than 5 tribal councils); rankings show them when the Survivor 51 filter is on.

Rank Player Original tribe Vote record Elo Season
1 Kilby Toka 12-0 1564.7 (B) +64.7
2 Maggie Toka 12-0 1561.2 (B) +61.2
3 Cristian Savu 7-0 1543.1 (B) +43.1
3 Eric Savu 7-0 1543.1 (B) +43.1
3 Sharonda Savu 7-0 1543.1 (B) +43.1
6 Kristin Savu 7-0 1539.3 (B) +39.3
7 Mike Toka 7-6 1519.7 (C) +19.7
8 Devin Toka 7-12 1515.2 (C) +15.2
8 Jelly Toka 7-12 1515.2 (C) +15.2
10 Thien An Toka 8-9 1507.7 (C) +7.7
11 Lewis Toka 5-9 1498.1 (C) -1.9
12 Carter Savu 5-16 1475.1 (C) -24.9

Eliminated

Player Original tribe Vote record Elo Season
Ori Savu 5-2 1517.5 (C) +17.5
Alexis Savu 4-3 1501.4 (C) +1.4
Linnea Savu 3-0 1499.9 (C) -0.1
Jenna Toka 5-4 1496.1 (C) -3.9
Patt Toka 3-6 1453.2 (D) -46.8
Aaliyah Toka 0-6 1440.0 (D) -60.0
Ana Savu 0-7 1436.0 (D) -64.0
Brady Toka 3-15 1419.8 (D) -80.2
Rob Savu 0-7 1410.7 (D) -89.3

Quick Hits

  • For the 3rd week in a row, the player voted out had the most confessionals of the episode: Alexis 6 in Episode 5, Ori 10 in Episode 6, Brady 7 in Episode 7.
  • Carter, Lewis and Thien An had 1 confessional each in Episode 7, the fewest of the episode with Cristian, and all 3 were on the wrong side of the vote.
  • No idol has been played in 7 episodes. The players left hold Jelly's and Carter's idols, the Tethered Idol, now with Sharonda, and Devin's extra vote. The only advantages used so far are the 2 extra votes Maggie gave Kilby and Lewis in Episode 5.

BEAST Update

This week 2 individual challenges counted, the grub challenge for a seat at the merge feast and the immunity challenge, with all 13 players in each. survivoR records the full finishing order for both, and BEAST scores every pair by who finished ahead: 78 matchups a challenge, 156 in all. A player who gave up, as Cristian and Kristin did at the grub challenge, is scored by where they finished.

Player Reward Immunity BEAST Change
Mike 3rd 1st 1638.9 (S) +118.2
Brady 1st 5th 1602.3 (A) +84.8
Lewis 8th 2nd 1565.8 (A) +57.4
Jelly 7th 4th 1532.4 (B) +52.8
Devin 5th 7th 1508.1 (B) +34.2
Carter 2nd 9th 1527.7 (B) +24.6
Kristin 13th 3rd 1498.0 (C) -7.9
Maggie 9th 6th 1501.4 (B) -10.6
Thien An 4th 12th 1469.5 (C) -42.4
Eric 6th 11th 1454.4 (C) -42.6
Kilby 10th 8th 1462.9 (C) -49.0
Cristian 12th 10th 1410.6 (D) -95.3
Sharonda 11th 13th 1375.8 (F) -124.2

Episode 7 has the 6 largest BEAST gains and the 5 largest drops of the season. Team challenges split each change across a tribe; in Episode 6 no player moved more than 11.4. Individual challenges at the merge put each player against 12 others twice.

Mike is S tier. Mike goes from 1520.7 to 1638.9, 13th of the 874 players BEAST rates, and keeps the highest BEAST in the cast. Brady, 2nd in the cast at 1602.3, leaves with it. Lewis is 3rd at 1565.8.

Sharonda is last in the cast. Sharonda finished 11th and 13th and drops to 1375.8, 871st of 874 and the lowest of the 21 in the cast. Cristian, 12th and 10th, is 2nd lowest at 1410.6.

PROBST reads these ratings as "challenge threat" and "not a challenge threat", which raise and lower a player's odds of going home. Mike, Lewis and Carter, PROBST's top 3 for immunity, have 3 of the 4 highest BEAST ratings left.


Explore the full rankings, player histories, season snapshots and predictions at survivorelo.com.

Thanks to Dan Oehm (@danoehm.bsky.social) for his survivoR R package, which provides the underlying data.

Player Profiles