← All posts

Survivor ELO Blog

PROBST, SHALLOW & BEAST Recap, Survivor 51 Episode 6

Published: 2026-10-30

PROBST's first pick goes home for the 2nd episode in a row: Ori, out 2-0 at Savu at 13.7%; if the merge comes in Episode 7, it has Eric at 11.1% to go home

TL;DR: For the second episode in a row, PROBST's first pick went home. Savu lost immunity, and Devin and Jelly voted Ori out 2-0 after Ori's Shot in the Dark came up not safe; PROBST had Ori at 13.7%, 1st of 14, and 51.7% if Savu voted. Through 7 boots its first pick has gone home twice, 29%, against 6% for picking at random. The preview showed the merge for Episode 7, which PROBST gives 75% without seeing it; if it comes, PROBST has Eric at 11.1% to go home and Cristian at 9.9%.


Episode Summary: SurvivorElo Episode 6

Quick refresher: PROBST (PRobabilistic Odds for Boots, Swaps and Tribals) forecasts each episode before it airs: who goes home, which tribe goes to tribal council, and whether the tribes swap or merge. Each recap scores the last forecast and sets out the next one; the Predictions page has this week's odds. Among its inputs are 2 ratings. SHALLOW rates strategic positioning (voting correctly + outlasting). BEAST rates challenge performance. Both use Elo, so gains and losses depend on relative ratings. Full methodology at survivorelo.com.


How PROBST Called Episode 6

PROBST published these odds before the episode aired. "If tribe votes" assumes the tribes stay and that tribe goes to tribal council.

Player Tribe Goes home If tribe votes Result
Ori Savu 13.7% 51.7% Voted out, 2-0
Devin Savu 11.6% 35.0% Voted Ori
Kristin Toka 8.4% 25.9% Toka won immunity; received an idol
Mike Toka 8.1% 20.2% Toka won immunity
Eric Dina 7.7% 17.0% Dina won immunity

The first pick, and the likeliest tribe. PROBST had Savu, down to 3 players, as the likeliest tribe to go to tribal council if the tribes stayed, at 45%, for worse challenge form this season and weaker challenge ratings. Dina was at 34% and Toka at 32%. Savu lost, and Ori, the only original Savu player on Savu, went home. The reasons PROBST gave for Ori were "original tribe in the minority" and "less airtime".

What it got wrong. PROBST gave the merge 57% this episode; the tribes stayed as they were. A swap was at 5%. It had 1 tribal council as the likeliest outcome, at 86%, and that is what happened.

Recomputed, Ori is at 13.4%. The track record below scores each forecast as recomputed with the current data, and this week's data changed a vote in Episode 5 (see "A Correction to Episode 5"). Recomputed, Ori moves from 13.7% to 13.4% and stays 1st of 14; the 51.7% if Savu voted does not change.

The Season So Far

Episode Voted out Forecast Rank If tribe votes
1 Aaliyah 5.0% 2nd of 20 10.0%
2 Ana 4.9% 14th of 19 10.6%
3 Patt 4.1% 15th of 19 8.8%
4 Jenna 6.0% 4th of 17 6.5%
5 Alexis 14.5% 1st of 16 37.3%
5 Linnea 3.3% 14th of 16 9.1%
6 Ori 13.4% 1st of 14 51.7%

Rob's quit in Episode 3 is not scored. The premiere forecast was close to flat: with 20 players who could be voted out, an even share is 5.0%.

Measure PROBST At random
First pick went home 29% (2 of 7) 6%
Boot in its top 3 43% (3 of 7) 18%
Boot in its top 5 57% (4 of 7) 29%
Average rank of the boot 7.29 9.14
Log loss (lower is better) 2.766 2.843

Log loss scores the probability a forecast gave the player who actually went home; a confident miss costs the most. After 4 boots PROBST had not yet ranked a boot 1st, and after 6 its log loss was worse than picking at random, 2.892 against 2.877. After 7 it is ahead on every measure in the table. A sample of 7 boots is small; the backtest on past seasons is on the Predictions page.


Episode 6: What Happened

Each tribe sent 1 player to a summit: Toka chose Kristin over Mike, Savu drew Ori at random, and Dina drew Sharonda after Cristian held back Kilby's and Lewis's dice. All 3 are original Savu. Of the 3, 2 had to take a meal back to camp and 1 had to spend the night on Exile. Kristin volunteered for Exile and received a Tethered Idol: only Kristin can play it, only for Ori or Sharonda, and it becomes a regular idol for Kristin once both are out. The 3 tribes played 1 challenge, for immunity, 3 players a side. Toka sat out Carter, Mike and Thien An, and Dina sat out Eric and Sharonda. Toka and Dina finished close together and both won immunity; Savu reached the puzzle early and could not finish it. At Savu, Devin suggested all 3 play a Shot in the Dark; Jelly refused and revealed the idol. Ori pitched Jelly against Devin and Devin against Jelly; Devin, holding an extra vote, considered it and stayed with Jelly. At tribal council Jelly did not play the idol, Devin did not use the extra vote, and Ori played a Shot in the Dark, which came up not safe. Devin and Jelly voted Ori out 2-0.


The Savu Vote

All 3 Savu players went to tribal council. Devin and Jelly voted Ori; Ori played a Shot in the Dark instead of voting. The outlast record counts Ori.

Player Original tribe Vote Vote record Outlast record Start End Change
Devin Toka Ori 1-0 1-0 1484.8 1493.9 (C) +9.1
Jelly Toka Ori 1-0 1-0 1484.8 1493.9 (C) +9.1
Ori Savu Shot in the Dark 0-2 0-2 1535.8 1517.5 (C) -18.3

PROBST's case was the original tribes. Ori was 1 original Savu player against 2 original Toka. PROBST had Ori at 51.7% if Savu voted, Devin at 35.0% and Jelly, with an idol, at 13.3%. Ori had 10 confessionals in Episode 6, the most of the episode, after 13 in Episodes 1 to 5.

A Shot in the Dark does not change the score. SHALLOW scores the player voted out as on the wrong side of the vote whether or not that player voted. Ori lost 4 matchups, 2 votes and 2 outlasts, at 4.6 points each. Ori went in 51.0 above Devin and Jelly, so the pair gain more than a level matchup would give.

Ori leaves as the highest rated player voted out this season. Ori was 5-0 on the vote going in and leaves 5-2 at 1517.5, +17.5 for the season. Alexis, at 1501.4, had been the highest.

Devin and Jelly are no longer provisional. Both have now attended 5 tribal councils, the first in the cast to reach 5, and join the rankings at 435th and 436th. They have voted together at all 5, and their 3-12 vote records are still the lowest left in the game. Savu is down to the 2 of them.


A Correction to Episode 5

At Dina in Episode 5 the vote tied 4-4 twice, and Cristian, Eric, Kilby and Sharonda had to agree on Lewis or Linnea or draw rocks. They agreed on Linnea. survivoR used to record that decision as a 3rd round of votes, 4 votes for Linnea. This week's data records it as a unanimous decision with no votes cast: Lewis saved, Linnea out. The recaps agree that no rocks were drawn and no 3rd vote was cast.

Player Vote record (was) Vote record (now) Elo (was) Elo (now) Change
Linnea 3-5 3-0 1480.3 1499.9 +19.6
Kilby 9-0 8-0 1550.2 1546.4 -3.8
Lewis 6-0 5-0 1535.8 1531.9 -3.9
Cristian 4-0 3-0 1527.5 1523.5 -4.0
Eric 4-0 3-0 1527.5 1523.5 -4.0
Sharonda 4-0 3-0 1527.5 1523.5 -4.0

No one at Dina scores a vote now. SHALLOW keeps each player's last entry at a tribal council, and the last entry for all 6 is the decision, which has no vote in it. The 2 tied rounds no longer count for anyone, including the 2 extra votes Kilby and Lewis cast; only the outlast does. Each of the 5 who stayed outlasted Linnea, worth 3.7 to 4.0 points, and Linnea lost those 5 outlasts, 19.6 in all, half of the 39.2 published last week. SHALLOW scores a rock draw the same way; in the data, the Survivor 27 tribal council that sent Katie to Redemption Island by rock draw ends with every player on a rock draw entry and no vote.

PROBST reads the same entries. Its voting features now see no votes cast at Dina in Episode 5, so it no longer counts the votes Lewis received in the 2 tied rounds, and on Dina it lists "no votes received" for Lewis. The Episode 5 snapshot no longer shows a vote count for Linnea; last week it showed 5-1.


What PROBST Expects in Episode 7

The preview at the end of Episode 6 showed a merged tribe. PROBST does not use previews; from the data it gives the merge 75% this episode and 12% in Episode 8. If the merge comes, these are its numbers:

Player Original tribe Goes home if merged Why
Eric Savu 11.1% original tribe in the minority; outside the largest bloc
Cristian Savu 9.9% original tribe in the minority; outside the largest bloc; right side of last vote pulls the other way
Sharonda Savu 9.7% original tribe in the minority; outside the largest bloc; right side of last vote pulls the other way
Kristin Savu 9.4% original tribe in the minority; outside the largest bloc; fewer tribals attended pulls the other way
Mike Toka 8.8% wrong side of last vote; challenge threat; in the largest bloc pulls the other way
Everyone else 6.2-8.4%
Jelly Toka 3.7% outside the largest bloc; not a challenge threat and original tribe in the majority pull the other way
Carter Savu 3.4% original tribe in the minority

With 13 players an even share is 7.7%. Original Toka has 8 of the 13 and original Savu 5, and "original tribe in the minority" raises the number for all 5: Carter, Cristian, Eric, Kristin and Sharonda. The top 4 are all original Savu. The 2 idol holders, Jelly and Carter, are lowest. For individual immunity PROBST has Brady at 9.5%, Carter at 9.3% and Cristian at 9.1%.

The largest bloc is 5 original Toka. From shared votes, PROBST groups Brady, Kilby, Maggie, Mike and Thien An, who have voted together 70% of the time on average, and Devin and Jelly, who always have. The other 6 are in no bloc. PROBST cannot see camp life: the recaps have Maggie and Thien An treating Mike as expendable, and Brady weighing Mike against Maggie, while PROBST counts Mike in the largest bloc and lowers Mike's number for it.

Kristin's idol counts for Sharonda. Kristin can play the Tethered Idol only for Ori or Sharonda, and it becomes a regular idol only once both are out. With Ori gone, PROBST counts it as an idol that can save Sharonda and not Kristin, so Kristin is at 9.4% if merged, 4th of 13, without the protection Jelly and Carter have. In the season simulation the idol becomes Kristin's own once Sharonda is out.

PROBST has no jury and 1 immunity winner. In Survivor 41 to 48 and 50, the first 1 to 3 players voted out after the merge did not make the jury, and in 41 to 46 about half the players were immune at the first merged vote. PROBST treats the merge as 1 tribe with 1 individual immunity winner, and its season odds have no number for making the jury.

Devin's 14.4% is the mix. The forecast PROBST is scored on mixes the merge (75%), a swap (3%) and the tribes staying as they are (22%). If the tribes stay, Savu, down to 2 players, goes to tribal council 50% of the time and Devin goes home 71.7% of the time when it does. That puts Devin at 14.4% across all 3, against 8.2% if merged; Eric is 2nd at 10.1%. The preview makes the 22% unlikely, so the Predictions page now leads with the merged numbers; the track record still scores the mix.

Season odds. The rest of the season is simulated 10,000 times.

Player Tribe Final 3 Wins Last week
Jelly Savu 33.4% 11.5% 11.3%
Carter Toka 32.1% 10.3% 10.1%
Lewis Dina 24.9% 9.1% 8.1%
Devin Savu 24.6% 8.8% 8.3%
Kilby Dina 23.2% 8.1% 7.2%

With 13 players an even share is 7.7%. The 2 idol holders are the top 2. Kristin is at 8.1%, level with Kilby and up from 5.9%, the largest rise of the week; Kristin's idol counts in the simulations where Sharonda goes first. Cristian has the lowest odds, 5.6%.

The season simulation merges the tribes in Episode 7 in every run, as the preview showed, because it does not keep a tribe of fewer than 3 players; the weekly forecast has no such rule, which is why it stops at 75%. PROBST has no votes from a merged tribe to read yet.


Season to Date: SHALLOW Rankings

Devin and Jelly are the first established players in the cast. The rest are provisional (fewer than 5 tribal councils); rankings show them when the Survivor 51 filter is on.

Rank Player Tribe Vote record Elo Season
1 Kilby Dina 8-0 1546.4 (B) +46.4
2 Maggie Toka 8-0 1542.7 (B) +42.7
2 Thien An Toka 8-0 1542.7 (B) +42.7
4 Lewis Dina 5-0 1531.9 (B) +31.9
5 Cristian Dina 3-0 1523.5 (C) +23.5
5 Eric Dina 3-0 1523.5 (C) +23.5
5 Sharonda Dina 3-0 1523.5 (C) +23.5
8 Kristin Toka 3-0 1519.5 (C) +19.5
9 Carter Toka 5-7 1505.9 (C) +5.9
10 Brady Toka 3-6 1498.8 (C) -1.2
10 Mike Toka 3-6 1498.8 (C) -1.2
12 Devin Savu 3-12 1493.9 (C) -6.1
12 Jelly Savu 3-12 1493.9 (C) -6.1

Eliminated

Player Tribe Vote record Elo Season
Ori Savu 5-2 1517.5 (C) +17.5
Alexis Savu 4-3 1501.4 (C) +1.4
Linnea Dina 3-0 1499.9 (C) -0.1
Jenna Savu 5-4 1496.1 (C) -3.9
Patt Toka 3-6 1453.2 (D) -46.8
Aaliyah Toka 0-6 1440.0 (D) -60.0
Ana Savu 0-7 1436.0 (D) -64.0
Rob Savu 0-7 1410.7 (D) -89.3

Quick Hits

  • For the second week, the player voted out had the most confessionals of the episode: Alexis 6 in Episode 5, Ori 10 in Episode 6. PROBST had named less airtime as a reason for both.
  • No idol has been played in 6 episodes. The players left hold 4 advantages: Jelly's and Carter's idols, Kristin's Tethered Idol and Devin's extra vote. Jelly revealed that idol at camp and did not play it. The only advantages used so far are the 2 extra votes Maggie gave Kilby and Lewis in Episode 5.
  • Cristian and Thien An have 9 confessionals each, the fewest of the 13 left. Devin has 36.

BEAST Update

This week 1 challenge counted, for immunity. Toka and Dina won and Savu lost. Toka sat out 3 players and Dina 2 to match Savu's 3: Carter, Mike and Thien An for Toka, Eric and Sharonda for Dina. BEAST scores the 6 players who competed for Toka and Dina as beating Savu's 3. Each winner gained 2.8 or 2.9, and each Savu player dropped about 11.3. The 5 who sat out did not move.

Group Result BEAST Change
Brady (Toka) Won immunity 1517.5 (B) +2.8
Kilby (Dina), Maggie (Toka) Won immunity 1512.0 (B) +2.8
Lewis (Dina) Won immunity 1508.4 (B) +2.9
Cristian (Dina), Kristin (Toka) Won immunity 1505.9 (B) +2.9
Mike (Toka) Sat out 1520.7 (B) 0.0
Thien An (Toka) Sat out 1511.9 (B) 0.0
Carter (Toka) Sat out 1503.1 (B) 0.0
Sharonda (Dina) Sat out 1500.0 (B) 0.0
Eric (Dina) Sat out 1497.0 (C) 0.0
Jelly (Savu) Lost 1479.7 (C) -11.4
Ori (Savu) Lost 1473.9 (C) -11.2
Devin (Savu) Lost 1473.9 (C) -11.2

Savu has lost all 3 challenges since the swap. Devin, Ori and Jelly now have the 3 lowest BEAST ratings of the 21 players in the cast. That record is why PROBST has Savu at 50% to go to tribal council if the tribes stay, with "worse challenge form this season" the larger of its 2 reasons. After a merge the same ratings work the other way: "not a challenge threat" lowers Devin's and Jelly's odds of going home.

Mike still has the highest BEAST in the cast, 1520.7, and Brady is 2nd at 1517.5. Toka's 6 players average 1511.9, Dina's 5 average 1504.7 and Savu's 2 average 1476.8. Kilby and Maggie reach 5 challenges, so every player left is now established in BEAST.


Explore the full rankings, player histories, season snapshots and predictions at survivorelo.com.

Thanks to Dan Oehm (@danoehm.bsky.social) for his survivoR R package, which provides the underlying data.

Player Profiles