Survivor ELO Blog
SHALLOW & BEAST Recap, Survivor 51 Episode 5
Published: 2026-10-23
Alexis out 3-1 at Savu, then Linnea out at Dina after 2 extra votes forced a deadlock; for Episode 6 PROBST gives the merge 57% and has Ori at 13.7% to go home
TL;DR: Toka won immunity, and Dina and Savu both went to tribal council. Alexis, PROBST's first pick at 14.5%, was voted out 3-1 at Savu. At Dina, 2 extra votes from Maggie forced a 4-4 tie and a 4-4 revote, and Cristian, Eric and Sharonda agreed to send Linnea home rather than draw rocks; Linnea goes from 1519.5 to 1480.3. For Episode 6 PROBST gives the merge 57%, and has Ori at 13.7% to go home and Devin at 11.6%.
Episode Summary: SurvivorElo Episode 5
Quick refresher: SHALLOW rates strategic positioning (voting correctly + outlasting). BEAST rates challenge performance. Both use Elo, so gains and losses depend on relative ratings. Full methodology at survivorelo.com.
PROBST (PRobabilistic Odds for Boots, Swaps and Tribals) forecasts each episode before it airs. The Predictions page has this week's odds; each recap scores the forecast for the episode that just aired and shows the one for the next.
Episode 5: What Happened
The 3 tribes played 1 challenge for reward and immunity, and 2 tribes went to tribal council. Dina and Toka each sat out 2 players to match Savu's 4: Cristian and Kilby for Dina, Kristin and Maggie for Toka. Toka won immunity and pastries; Dina and Savu lost. Maggie, drawn at random from 3 Toka volunteers, went to Dina's camp and received an Alliance Builder Extra Vote, which had to go to a player on a tribe going to tribal council. Maggie gave Kilby and Lewis 1 extra vote each, this one and the one Maggie had held since Episode 3, and asked them to vote out Linnea; sources differ on which went to whom. At Savu, Alexis wanted Devin out and counted on Ori; Ori stayed with Devin and Jelly. Alexis was voted out 3-1: Devin, Jelly and Ori voted Alexis, and Alexis voted Devin. At Dina, Kilby and Lewis cast 2 votes each for Linnea, and Cristian, Eric, Linnea and Sharonda voted Lewis. The vote tied 4-4, and the revote tied 4-4 again. Under the deadlock rule, Cristian, Eric, Kilby and Sharonda had to agree on Lewis or Linnea, or the 4 of them would draw rocks. Kilby held out for rocks to keep Lewis. Eric agreed to Linnea first, then Sharonda, then Cristian, and Linnea was sent home. Jelly kept the idol and Devin the extra vote. No one played an idol or a Shot in the Dark.
The Dina Vote
All 6 players at Dina's tribal council voted. The outlast record counts Linnea.
| Player | Original tribe | Vote | Deadlock | Vote record | Outlast record | Start | End | Change |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Kilby | Toka | Linnea, 2 votes | Linnea | 1-0 | 1-0 | 1542.7 | 1550.2 (B) | +7.5 |
| Lewis | Toka | Linnea, 2 votes | Tied | 1-0 | 1-0 | 1528.0 | 1535.8 (B) | +7.8 |
| Cristian | Savu | Lewis | Linnea | 1-0 | 1-0 | 1519.5 | 1527.5 (C) | +8.0 |
| Eric | Savu | Lewis | Linnea | 1-0 | 1-0 | 1519.5 | 1527.5 (C) | +8.0 |
| Sharonda | Savu | Lewis | Linnea | 1-0 | 1-0 | 1519.5 | 1527.5 (C) | +8.0 |
| Linnea | Savu | Lewis | Tied | 0-5 | 0-5 | 1519.5 | 1480.3 (C) | -39.2 |
The deadlock decision counts as the vote. Cristian, Eric and Sharonda voted Lewis twice and then agreed to Linnea. SHALLOW keeps each player's last vote, so it scores the 3 of them as voting Linnea, the same as Kilby and Lewis. Each of the 5 beat Linnea on the vote and outlasted Linnea, 2 matchups each. survivoR records the decision as a 3rd round of votes, a label that appears in no other season in the data. The Episode 5 snapshot lists the result as 5-1, counting each player's last vote.
SHALLOW counts a player once. Kilby and Lewis cast 2 votes each, and the model scores each of them once, so the extra votes add nothing to their ratings. Without the extra votes, the 4 original Savu players outnumbered Kilby and Lewis 4-2. Maggie, Kilby and Lewis are all original Toka. Kilby is now 9-0 on the vote and +50.2 for the season, the most in the cast, and leads SHALLOW alone at 1550.2; last week Kilby was tied with Maggie and Thien An.
Linnea lost to 5 players. A player voted out loses only to the players at that tribal council. Linnea lost 10 matchups, 5 votes and 5 outlasts, at 3.7 to 4.0 points each. Linnea was 3-0 going in and leaves 3-5 at 1480.3, -19.7 for the season.
The Savu Vote
All 4 players at Savu's tribal council voted. The outlast record counts Alexis.
| Player | Original tribe | Vote | Vote record | Outlast record | Start | End | Change |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Ori | Savu | Alexis | 1-0 | 1-0 | 1527.8 | 1535.8 (B) | +8.0 |
| Devin | Toka | Alexis | 1-0 | 1-0 | 1475.6 | 1484.8 (C) | +9.2 |
| Jelly | Toka | Alexis | 1-0 | 1-0 | 1475.6 | 1484.8 (C) | +9.2 |
| Alexis | Savu | Devin | 0-3 | 0-3 | 1527.8 | 1501.4 (C) | -26.4 |
Ori sided with Devin and Jelly. The 3 of them have voted together at both tribal councils they have shared, and Devin and Jelly have voted together at all 4 of theirs. Savu is down to those 3. Devin and Jelly are 2-12 on the vote, the lowest records left in the game.
The lower rated pair gains more. Devin and Jelly went in 52.2 below Alexis and gain +9.2 each; Ori went in level with Alexis and gains +8.0. Alexis lost 4.6 points in each matchup with Devin and Jelly and 4.0 in each with Ori.
Alexis leaves above 1500. Alexis was 4-0 going in and leaves 4-3 at 1501.4, +1.4 for the season. No other player voted out this season left above 1500.
The Original Tribes
Both players voted out were original Savu. Lewis, who started on Exile and joined Toka in Episode 2, counts with Toka. Carter, who moved to Toka in Episode 3, counts with Savu.
| Original tribe | Started | Gone | Left | On Dina | On Savu | On Toka |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Toka | 11 | 3 | 8 | 2 | 2 | 4 |
| Savu | 10 | 4 | 6 | 3 | 1 | 2 |
Original Savu has lost Ana, Rob, Alexis and Linnea, and original Toka Aaliyah, Patt and Jenna. If the tribes merge, original Toka has 8 of the 14. In PROBST's merge forecast, "original tribe in the minority" raises the number for all 6 original Savu players: Carter, Cristian, Eric, Kristin, Ori and Sharonda.
What PROBST Expects
Scoring Episode 5. PROBST had Alexis at 14.5%, 1st of 16, and 37.3% if Savu voted; it is the first time this season its first pick went home. It had Linnea at 3.3%, 14th of 16, and 9.1% if Dina voted, 5th of 6 on the tribe. On Dina it had Kilby at 39.4%, for the 5 votes Kilby drew in Episode 3; the original Savu players voted for Lewis, at 12.7%. PROBST counts idols but not extra votes, and the 2 extra votes decided the Dina vote. Savu (43%) and Dina (32%) went to tribal council, and Toka (37%) won; PROBST gave 2 or more tribal councils 12%. Through 6 boots its first pick has gone home once, and the player who left was in its top 3 twice; picking at random would be right 6% and 17% of the time. The Episode 5 snapshot shows the forecast under "Before this episode"; recomputed with the current data, it matches the published numbers.
Episode 6. PROBST gives the merge 57% this episode and 32% in Episode 7. If the tribes stay as they are, Savu, down to 3 players, is the likeliest to go to tribal council, at 45%, for worse challenge form this season and weaker challenge ratings. Dina is at 34%, for better challenge form this season, and Toka at 32%, for better challenge form and stronger challenge ratings. An episode can have 2 tribal councils, so the 3 add to more than 100%. A tribe swap has a 5% chance. The episode most likely has 1 tribal council (86%), and there is a 15% chance of 2 eliminations.
| Player | Tribe | Goes home | If tribe votes | Why |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Ori | Savu | 13.7% | 51.7% | original tribe in the minority; less airtime |
| Devin | Savu | 11.6% | 35.0% | received votes last tribal; more airtime pulls the other way |
| Kristin | Toka | 8.4% | 25.9% | original tribe in the minority; right side of last vote pulls the other way |
| Mike | Toka | 8.1% | 20.2% | wrong side of last vote |
| Eric | Dina | 7.7% | 17.0% | in the largest bloc and original tribe in the majority pull the other way |
| Everyone else | 5.4-7.6% | 12.9-29.3% | ||
| Jelly | Savu | 4.5% | 13.3% | an idol and original tribe in the majority pull the other way |
| Carter | Toka | 3.1% | 9.5% | original tribe in the minority; outside the largest bloc; an idol pulls the other way |
"Goes home" is across the merge, a swap and the tribes staying. "If tribe votes" assumes the tribes stay and that tribe goes to tribal council.
Ori is the only original Savu player on Savu and has the highest number of any player if the tribe votes, 51.7%. Devin drew Alexis's vote; Devin has 29 confessionals, the most in the cast, and Ori 13. Jelly's idol keeps Jelly at 13.3% on Savu. On Dina, Kilby (29.3%) and Lewis (24.5%) are the 2 original Toka players, outside the largest bloc of Cristian, Eric and Sharonda.
If the tribes merge, these 5 are the most likely to go home:
| Player | Goes home if merged | Why |
|---|---|---|
| Mike | 9.2% | wrong side of last vote |
| Devin | 9.1% | received votes last tribal; more tribals attended |
| Eric | 8.8% | original tribe in the minority |
| Kristin | 8.6% | outside the largest bloc; fewer tribals attended pulls the other way |
| Brady | 8.5% | wrong side of last vote |
With 14 players an even share is 7.1%. The 2 idol holders are lowest, Jelly at 3.5% and Carter at 3.2%. Kilby is at 6.1% if merged, against 29.3% if Dina votes; in a merged tribe PROBST puts Kilby in the largest bloc.
Season odds. The rest of the season is simulated 10,000 times.
| Player | Tribe | Reaches merge | Final 3 | Wins |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Jelly | Savu | 96.8% | 32.1% | 11.3% |
| Carter | Toka | 97.9% | 30.5% | 10.1% |
| Devin | Savu | 92.6% | 22.8% | 8.3% |
| Lewis | Dina | 95.1% | 22.9% | 8.1% |
| Brady | Toka | 96.3% | 23.9% | 8.1% |
The same 5 lead as last week; Jelly moves ahead of Carter, and the 2 idol holders are 1st and 2nd. Kilby rises from 5.6% to 7.2% and Maggie from 4.4% to 6.2%. Ori and Sharonda have the lowest odds, 5.5%.
If the merge comes this week, PROBST spreads the 14 players from 3.2% to 9.2%; it has no votes from a merged tribe to read yet.
Season to Date: SHALLOW Rankings
All rated players are provisional (fewer than 5 tribal councils). Rankings show provisional players when the Survivor 51 filter is on.
| Rank | Player | Tribe | Vote record | Elo | Season |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Kilby | Dina | 9-0 | 1550.2 (B) | +50.2 |
| 2 | Maggie | Toka | 8-0 | 1542.7 (B) | +42.7 |
| 2 | Thien An | Toka | 8-0 | 1542.7 (B) | +42.7 |
| 4 | Lewis | Dina | 6-0 | 1535.8 (B) | +35.8 |
| 4 | Ori | Savu | 5-0 | 1535.8 (B) | +35.8 |
| 6 | Cristian | Dina | 4-0 | 1527.5 (C) | +27.5 |
| 6 | Eric | Dina | 4-0 | 1527.5 (C) | +27.5 |
| 6 | Sharonda | Dina | 4-0 | 1527.5 (C) | +27.5 |
| 9 | Kristin | Toka | 3-0 | 1519.5 (C) | +19.5 |
| 10 | Carter | Toka | 5-7 | 1505.9 (C) | +5.9 |
| 11 | Brady | Toka | 3-6 | 1498.8 (C) | -1.2 |
| 11 | Mike | Toka | 3-6 | 1498.8 (C) | -1.2 |
| 13 | Devin | Savu | 2-12 | 1484.8 (C) | -15.2 |
| 13 | Jelly | Savu | 2-12 | 1484.8 (C) | -15.2 |
Eliminated
| Player | Tribe | Vote record | Elo | Season |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Alexis | Savu | 4-3 | 1501.4 (C) | +1.4 |
| Jenna | Savu | 5-4 | 1496.1 (C) | -3.9 |
| Linnea | Dina | 3-5 | 1480.3 (C) | -19.7 |
| Patt | Toka | 3-6 | 1453.2 (D) | -46.8 |
| Aaliyah | Toka | 0-6 | 1440.0 (D) | -60.0 |
| Ana | Savu | 0-7 | 1436.0 (D) | -64.0 |
| Rob | Savu | 0-7 | 1410.7 (D) | -89.3 |
Quick Hits
- No idol has been played this season. Kilby and Lewis used the 2 extra votes from Maggie. Jelly's and Carter's idols and Devin's extra vote, the 3 advantages left, are still held.
- Alexis had 6 confessionals in Episode 5, the most of the episode, after 9 in Episodes 1 to 4. PROBST had named less airtime as the reason for Alexis's 14.5%.
- Cristian has 5 confessionals in 5 episodes, the fewest of the players left. Devin has 29.
BEAST Update
This week 1 challenge counted, reward and immunity together. Toka won, and Dina and Savu both lost; BEAST scores the 4 Toka players who competed as beating the 8 from Dina and Savu, and does not score Dina against Savu. Each Toka player gained 11.6 to 12.2, and each player on Dina and Savu dropped about 3.0. The 4 who sat out did not move.
| Group | Result | BEAST | Change |
|---|---|---|---|
| Mike (Toka) | Won immunity | 1520.7 (B) | +11.6 |
| Brady (Toka) | Won immunity | 1514.8 (B) | +11.8 |
| Thien An (Toka) | Won immunity | 1511.9 (B) | +11.9 |
| Carter (Toka) | Won immunity | 1503.1 (B) | +12.2 |
| Kilby (Dina), Maggie (Toka) | Sat out | 1509.2 (B) | 0.0 |
| Cristian (Dina), Kristin (Toka) | Sat out | 1503.0 (B) | 0.0 |
| Lewis (Dina) | Lost | 1505.6 (B) | -3.1 |
| Linnea, Sharonda (Dina) | Lost | 1500.0 (B) | -3.0 |
| Eric (Dina) | Lost | 1497.0 (C) | -3.0 |
| Jelly (Savu) | Lost | 1491.1 (C) | -2.9 |
| Alexis, Ori (Savu) | Lost | 1485.2 (C) | -2.9 |
| Devin (Savu) | Lost | 1485.1 (C) | -2.9 |
Mike now has the highest BEAST in the cast, 1520.7, and Brady is 2nd at 1514.8. Carter's +12.2 is the largest gain of the week and moves Carter from C to B tier; Eric drops from B to C. Toka's 6 players average 1510.4, Dina's 5 average 1503.0 and Savu's 3 average 1487.1. Savu's 3 have the 3 lowest BEAST ratings left, and PROBST names Savu's weaker challenge ratings as a reason it is the likeliest tribe to go to tribal council. Kilby and Maggie, with 4 challenges each, are the only players left still provisional in BEAST.
Explore the full rankings, player histories, season snapshots and predictions at survivorelo.com.
Thanks to Dan Oehm (@danoehm.bsky.social) for his survivoR R package, which provides the underlying data.